Do fish dream?

12 comments / Posted on / by

Day Dream Believer Photo by Louis Cahill

Ah, there’s the rub, for what dreams may come in that sleep of fish?

Have you ever been sight fishing to a nice fish and not gotten so much as a look at your fly? The fish just sat quietly finning as your fly drifted inches from its nose, like it was asleep. It may have been.

Do fish sleep? Undoubtedly. That’s a scientific fact that is well documented. They don’t sleep like we do and, in fact, different species of fish have very different ways of sleeping. Some sleep at night, some during the day and some are nappers. Some swim while asleep and some sleep so soundly that you can hold them in your hand without waking them.

Tuna, for example, rest motionless at night, suspended in the water. Bass and perch will sleep under or on top of logs. Reef fish seek refuge in crevices. Parrotfish build a cocoon of mucus in which to sleep. That sounds nasty, but maybe that’s the point. I wouldn’t eat something wrapped in mucus. Would you?

Although different fishes have different sleep habits they have a lot in common. Fish don’t have eye lids so they don’t exactly get shut eye. Their muscles relax, their breathing and heart rate slow, they become to some degree immobile and less sensitive to external stimuli. They also, to some extent, lose consciousness.

Fish do not live in as safe a world as we do and sleeping can be a risky proposition. For that reason most fish are never completely unconscious. Their brains sleep in shifts, resting different systems at different times. Shutting down nonessential bodily functions for periods of time. I imagine it’s much like day dreaming. Like when your brain is back on the beach in the Bahamas while your body seems to be looking over spread sheets at your desk. You’re not fully aware of your surroundings but alert enough to figure out that the sound you hear is your boss clearing his throat.

But what about those dreams? I’m not aware of any scientific studies about fish dreams. I do, however, have a case for their likely existence. Bear with me, this requires a huge and very unscientific leap. Let’s assume, for the minute, that a fish’s brain has some similar wiring to our own.

What is going on when we dream?

Dreaming is our brain’s way of filing information. Let’s use the clumsy but common metaphor of the computer. Our short term memory is like the RAM. After a full day of sensory input, the RAM is full. We know where we put our car keys and what we had for breakfast and maybe a few of the things our spouse asked us to do but it’s all just raw data. In order to put this input into deeper context it must be filed with like experiences. Then our brain can draw the comparisons that are crucial to learning. “I keep thinking about the Bahamas while I should be working and I keep getting fired, hummmm?”

The process of dreaming sorts all of that complex data, stores it, prioritizes it and clears the buffer for the next day’s experience. Without our dreams our brains cannot make sense of our experience and we cannot learn. It has been proven that sleep deprivation is the fastest rout to psychosis. We must dream.

It will not be difficult to make the case to fly fisherman that fish learn. Sometimes faster than we do. An experiment at the Univercity of Oviedo in Spain proved that angelfish learn. For three weeks food was delivered to one corner of the tank in the morning and the opposite corner in the evening. With no outside stimuli like sun or tide the fish soon congregated in the appropriate corner just before the appropriate feeding time. Apparently fish not only learn but they can tell time.

Experiments at the Manomet Center of Conservation Science which involved training haddock to swim through nets indicated that fish learn from watching older, more experienced fish. That’s pretty advanced learning skills. Certainly there is some data processing going on there. How is all of that data being managed if not with dreams?

I have always been told that I have crazy dreams. They range from short to epic, detailed to impressionistic, blissful to horrific. Many of them involve fish. When I am stressed I have indicator dreams where I watch a strike indicator drift through the same run again and again without a strike. They can go on for hours. When times are better I go on wild fishing adventures and sometimes I am the fish. After a particularly nasty bit of dentistry I dreamed that I was a steelhead with a big hook in my jaw. The guy who hooked me had not crushed the barb and he kept wrenching and wrenching at the hook but it wouldn’t come free.

I don’t know what fish dream about. Maybe they dream of the Mothers-day hatch or of shad kills. Perhaps they dream of herons or bears. Maybe they dream that they are birds soaring in the clouds. I like to think that once in a while they dream of me.

“I was just there, in that big slow run, you know the one. I was eating caddis flies and all of a sudden I was just yanked up out of the water. It was like I was swimming but I wasn’t going anywhere. Nobody would help me and I just kept getting hauled up out of the water and then, from nowhere, there was this big guy, like huge with a beard. He picked me up with both hands and he kissed me. There was a bright flash of light and I was back in the water. I think he was God. What do you think it means?”

Come fish with us in the Bahamas!

Louis Cahill
Gink & Gasoline
Sign Up For Our Weekly Newsletter!

Follow Gink & Gasoline on Facebook:

12 thoughts on “Do fish dream?

  1. My reoccurring dream is running a spinner bait down a perfect shore line. I can see the vegetation, the intersection of feeder creeks and even feel the blades turning on a chartreuse and white spinner bait but never a strike. What do you think, should I change colors or add a trailer?
    awh!!! Sweet Fish Kisses

  2. Really cool post Louis! Gotta say I’ve never read anything about fish sleeping habits, or dreaming. Maybe fish do have dreams….. and nightmares. If it was one of our ugly mugs that a fish dreamt about, it’d probably be filed in the nightmares category. Really cool photo too!

  3. Great post as always! I have a reoccurring dream in an unknown location watching my strike indicator drift perfectly along the feeding lane of a chute when…WHAM! My indicator disappears and I wake up. I’ve never been fishing for steelhead but everything about the dream feels like a steelhead experience. Plus, I think about the prospect of a steelhead adventure about every 8 seconds. I believe my first time pursuit of steelhead is the only way to see this dream to completion! Thanks for all the great posts. Hands down, best blog in town.

  4. Pingback: Fish Dreams | Skiff Republic

  5. A while back, maybe ten or fifteen years or so, I was paddling my canoe in a very shallow and wide section of a warm water stream that is locally called the bathtub when I came upon a crappie about 5 inches long, sitting stationary in a small opening of a rather large weed bed. Usually when I came upon fish they scattered into the weeds, this one did not; it just stayed there pretty much motionless. I watched it for about 5 minutes before I slowly worked my way almost on top of it and reached down ( the water was about 15 inches deep) and picked it up. As I pulled the fish out of the water it flipped once and hit the water and was gone. To this day it is one of the stranger things I have witnessed; it was mid morning and I think it was sleeping; I cant think of any other explanation for it.

  6. Pingback: Trout Fishing and the Full Moon | Fly Fishing | Gink and Gasoline | How to Fly Fish | Trout Fishing | Fly Tying | Fly Fishing Blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Captcha loading...